16, 1999 8:09 PM
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Marc Schindler/Mark Soler, Youth Law Center (202) 637-0377 Vincent Schiraldi/Jason
Ziedenberg, Justice Policy Institute (202) 678-9282
Votes To Incarcerate 13-year-olds With Adults And Federalize Local Crimes; Congressman
McCollum's Subterfuge Cuts Off Debate Over Controversial Measures
- June 16 - In a shameless attempt to divert attention from their effort to defeat
gun control measures, conservative House Republicans led the charge to push through
draconian juvenile justice legislation which had failed to become law in the last
three years. The measure, offered by Congressman Bill McCollum (R-FL-8th) would
result in giving federal prosecutors unfettered discretion to try youth as young
as 13-years-old in adult court and create new mandatory sentencing requirements
for youthful offenders. The McCollum amendment, containing controversial provisions
which had drawn severe criticism in recent years, has gone largely unnoticed by
the public and media as debate has focused on gun control and cultural issues.
In taking this action, McCollum has thrown out the juvenile justice legislation
which he had written and cosponsored and which was unanimously agreed to just
over a month ago in the House Judiciary's Crime Subcommittee. In its place, McCollum
pushed through controversial legislation which would result in children being
incarcerated in adult correctional facilities, where studies have already shown
that juveniles are in much greater danger compared to youth held in juvenile facilities.
The research has shown that youth in adult prisons are eight times more likely
to commit suicide and five times more likely to be raped and sexually abused than
youth held in juvenile facilities.
Because the Republican leadership by-passed the full Judiciary Committee and sent
the juvenile crime legislation directly to the House floor, there was limited
debate and no testimony or hearings on these highly controversial provisions.
Further, the leadership's maneuver disallowed voting on ammendments which would
have funded crime prevention. "Congressman McCollum is once again exhibiting the
mean-spirited and irrational approach we've seen him try in the past," stated
Mark Soler, President of the Youth Law Center. "This year, he has added a new
twist to his tactics, a legislative sleight-of-hand to cut off debate on this
important public safety issue."
Vincent Schiraldi, Director of the Justice Policy Institute, noted that in 1998,
his organization and the Youth Law Center conducted a public opinion survey which
found that respondents opposed giving prosecutors sole discretion to try juveniles
as adults by a 56% to 41% margin, with almost twice as many respondents opposing
the idea strongly (29%) as those supporting the idea strongly (16%). "This isn't
public policy, it's an excuse for public policy which isn't even popular with
the public," Schiraldi noted. "Of all people, Congressman McCollum, as a former
House Prosecutor in the impeachment proceedings, ought to know that this is not
the year to be extending the unfettered reach of prosecutors."
Marc Schindler, Staff Attorney with the Youth Law Center, "In the three years
Congressman McCollum has had juvenile justice legislation pending, he never once
mentioned mandatory sentences for juveniles. Congressman McCollum's pandering
and reckless actions will do nothing to keep our kids and communities safe." Schindler
also noted that there are stacks of research, much of it funded by Congress, which
speak to the ineffectiveness of mandatory sentences and the fact that they often
fall most heavily on minorities. The Justice Policy Institute is a policy development
a research body which promotes effective and sensible approaches to reforming
America's justice system.
The Youth Law Center is a national public interest law firm dedicated to protecting
the rights of minors nationwide. For more information on the juvenile justice
legislation and other juvenile crime initiatives, please contact the Justice Policy
Institute at (202) 678-9282, or the Youth Law Center at (202) 637-0377. You can
visit JPI's website at www.cjcj.org, or page
Vincent Schiraldi at (800)581-1572.
|Common Dreams NewsCenter is a non-profit news service
providing breaking news and views for the Progressive Community.
press release posted here has been provided to Common Dreams NewsWire by
one of the many progressive organizations who make up America's Progressive Community.
you wish to comment on this press release or would like more information,
please contact the organization directly.
*all times Eastern US (GMT-5:00)
E-mail us your news release! firstname.lastname@example.org
© Copyrighted 1997-2000
All Rights Reserved. Common Dreams. www.commondreams.org